AUSTIN, Texas — Federal attorneys have acknowledged in court that an American citizen was deported to Mexico earlier this year, while simultaneously asking a federal judge to dismiss the man’s lawsuit on grounds that the government has immunity in immigration enforcement matters. The acknowledgment, disclosed November 20, concerns Brian José Morales García, an Austin resident whose removal followed a routine traffic stop in Central Texas.

U.S. Attorney Justin R. Simmons identified Morales García as a dual citizen of the United States and Mexico in a motion submitted to U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman in Austin. The filing marks the clearest acknowledgment by the Trump administration of Morales García’s American citizenship after immigration authorities previously disputed his account and maintained that he had entered the country illegally.

The new position does not resolve the litigation. Instead, federal lawyers are seeking to end the case without a trial by arguing that the government is immune from the claims arising from its immigration enforcement activities. The judge has not ruled on the motion, according to reporting published November 20 by The Texas Tribune.

Morales García, who was born in Denver and raised in Mexico, was living in Austin when the incident occurred. On April 3, he was traveling with coworkers in a pickup truck to install an air-conditioning system when a Texas Department of Public Safety trooper stopped the vehicle near Fredericksburg. State authorities previously said the traffic stop involved a window-tint violation.

According to earlier accounts from the Texas Department of Public Safety, the trooper requested assistance from local officers to communicate with passengers in the vehicle. Officers from the Gillespie County Sheriff’s Office and Fredericksburg Police Department became involved, and federal immigration authorities were contacted. The encounter eventually resulted in Morales García being taken into federal immigration custody.

Morales García has maintained that he told officers he was an American citizen and could provide documentation establishing his birthplace. He said his birth certificate and Social Security card were available at his home in Austin. Nevertheless, immigration authorities proceeded with his removal, sending him to Mexico on April 7.

At the time, the Department of Homeland Security publicly disputed his citizenship claim. Customs and Border Protection officials said their records indicated that Morales García was unlawfully present and that he had acknowledged entering the country illegally. Morales García challenged that account, telling The Texas Tribune that immigration agents had accused him of lying when he explained how he entered the United States.

He said he had traveled from Mexico through the El Paso port of entry in January 2025 and presented his American birth certificate to border authorities. According to his account, officials allowed him to enter. During the later detention, he said agents threatened him with imprisonment and pressured him to say he entered the country illegally. Those allegations remain part of the dispute over how his immigration case was handled.

The citizenship question became central to a lawsuit filed in May against federal immigration authorities, the Texas Department of Public Safety and the Gillespie County Sheriff’s Office. Morales García alleges that his detention and deportation violated his rights and seeks monetary damages in an unspecified amount.

A federal courthouse in Texas, where a lawsuit concerning the deportation of a U.S. citizen is being considered.

His attorneys subsequently submitted additional records supporting his claim that he was born in Colorado. Those materials included hospital documentation, witness affidavits and a certified birth record. In August, federal authorities reached an agreement with his legal team allowing him to return to the United States while the lawsuit continued.

Morales García returned on August 30. His attorney, Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch, met him in Laredo, Texas, according to the Tribune. The agreement allowing his return was an important procedural development, but it did not settle the civil claims arising from his earlier detention and removal.

The case also involved discrepancies between his American and Mexican identification documents. Earlier reporting established that his Mexican records used a different spelling of his first name, Bryan rather than Brian, and listed a different birth date. His mother attributed the discrepancies to mistakes made when his information was registered in Mexico during his childhood.

Those inconsistencies became part of the broader dispute over his identity. His family maintained that the differences in documentation did not change the fact that he was born in Denver. The federal government’s November filing now explicitly recognizes his dual citizenship, substantially narrowing the disagreement over his legal status.

However, the government’s acknowledgment is distinct from an admission that every action taken by enforcement officials was unlawful. Its motion asks the court to dismiss the lawsuit based on a legal defense concerning government immunity. The court must determine whether the asserted immunity applies to the claims presented, regardless of the government’s recognition of Morales García’s citizenship.

The distinction is significant because a U.S. citizen is not subject to removal under the civil immigration provisions used to deport foreign nationals. The litigation therefore raises two separate issues: how a citizen came to be removed from the United States and whether the government or other defendants can be held legally responsible for what happened.

The incident has also renewed attention to cooperation between state and local police agencies and federal immigration authorities. Texas has expanded participation in federal immigration enforcement programs, including agreements commonly known as 287(g) partnerships. These arrangements permit designated state and local law enforcement personnel to perform certain immigration-related functions under federal supervision.

Both the Texas Department of Public Safety and the Gillespie County Sheriff’s Office have participated in federal immigration enforcement partnerships, according to earlier Texas Tribune reporting. Their involvement in the traffic stop underscores the questions surrounding how officers verify citizenship and determine when to involve immigration agents.

A federal courthouse in Texas, where a lawsuit concerning the deportation of a U.S. citizen is being considered.

Questions about mistaken enforcement actions involving citizens have previously drawn attention from federal oversight authorities. In a July 2021 report, the U.S. Government Accountability Office found that available Immigration and Customs Enforcement records indicated 674 arrests, 121 detentions and 70 removals involving people identified as potential U.S. citizens between fiscal year 2015 and the second quarter of fiscal year 2020.

Those figures refer to potential citizens identified in agency data and do not establish that every individual was definitively a U.S. citizen. The watchdog also found inconsistencies in immigration agency procedures for investigating citizenship claims and deficiencies in tracking enforcement encounters involving possible citizens.

The GAO recommended improvements to training and recordkeeping, emphasizing that immigration agencies needed more reliable information about cases involving citizenship questions. The findings provide context for the Morales García dispute, although they predate his deportation and do not establish why officers failed to recognize his citizenship.

More recently, a ProPublica investigation identified more than 170 American citizens detained by immigration agents during the first nine months of President Donald Trump’s second administration. That investigation concerned detention incidents and did not establish that all those individuals were deported. Morales García’s case involves the additional circumstance of an actual removal followed by an agreement permitting his return.

The latest federal filing also leaves unresolved the positions of the other defendants named in Morales García’s lawsuit. Federal immunity arguments do not automatically establish the legal status of claims against state or local agencies, which may involve separate questions about the officers’ actions, authority and applicable defenses.

The Department of Homeland Security and Texas Department of Public Safety did not immediately respond to questions from The Texas Tribune concerning the latest filing. No additional ruling from Judge Pitman was reported in the coverage available through November 21.

Morales García has returned to work and resumed his life in Texas, but he has publicly expressed concern about the possibility of another encounter with law enforcement. The unresolved lawsuit remains the principal means through which he is seeking accountability for his detention and deportation.

For the federal court, the immediate question is whether the government’s immunity argument warrants dismissal. The November 20 filing establishes that federal lawyers now recognize Morales García as an American citizen, but the legal consequences of his removal remain undecided. Whether the case proceeds toward further litigation or ends through dismissal will depend on the court’s examination of the claims and defenses before it.

Leave a Reply

Trending