The Trump administration has acknowledged in a federal court filing that Brian José Morales García, an Austin man deported to Mexico earlier this year, is a dual citizen of the United States and Mexico. The admission came November 20 as federal attorneys asked a judge in Austin to dismiss a lawsuit challenging his detention and removal, arguing that the federal government has immunity in immigration enforcement matters.
U.S. Attorney Justin R. Simmons identified Morales García as a dual citizen in a motion filed before U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman in the Western District of Texas. The statement represents the clearest acknowledgment by a Trump administration official of Morales García’s American citizenship after federal immigration authorities previously maintained that he was in the country illegally.
The case stems from an April 3 traffic stop near Fredericksburg, Texas. Morales García was riding as a passenger in a pickup truck with coworkers who were traveling to an air-conditioning installation job when a Texas Department of Public Safety trooper stopped the vehicle over an alleged window-tint violation.
According to previous reporting by The Texas Tribune, Morales García did not have identification documents with him during the stop. He told the officers that he was born in the United States and had a birth certificate and Social Security card at his home in Austin that could establish his citizenship. However, local officers contacted immigration authorities, and federal agents subsequently took custody of him.
Gillespie County Sheriff’s Office deputies and Fredericksburg police officers were also involved in the response to the traffic stop. The involvement of multiple local agencies ultimately brought the encounter into the federal immigration enforcement system, setting in motion the events that led to Morales García’s deportation.
Morales García was born in Denver, Colorado, and spent much of his childhood growing up in Mexico. His mother, María del Socorro García, previously described how the family moved from Mexico to Denver in 1999 before returning to Mexico with their children in 2002. The family had initially traveled to the United States before deciding to raise their sons in Mexico.
In April, federal immigration officials disputed Morales García’s citizenship claim. A U.S. Customs and Border Protection spokesperson told The Texas Tribune that agents had determined through record checks that he was in the United States illegally. The spokesperson also maintained that Morales García had acknowledged being a Mexican national and having entered the country unlawfully.
Morales García offered a different account of his interactions with immigration officers. He said he repeatedly explained that he had entered the United States legally through the El Paso port of entry and could provide documentation proving his birthplace and citizenship. He also said agents accused him of lying and threatened that he could face imprisonment. According to his account, he eventually told them that he had entered illegally because he felt pressured during questioning.

He was held for five days before being removed to Mexico on April 7. Morales García previously said he agreed to a rapid deportation process because he feared that continued detention could last for months. He wanted to reunite with his wife and newborn daughter, who were living in Mexico at the time.
The disagreement over his citizenship subsequently became the central issue in a civil rights lawsuit filed by his attorneys in federal court on May 1. The lawsuit names federal immigration officials and agencies, Texas Department of Public Safety officers and Gillespie County sheriff’s personnel. It challenges the circumstances surrounding his detention and deportation and seeks an unspecified amount of financial compensation.
Morales García’s legal team maintained that authorities had ignored his repeated assertions of American citizenship and failed to adequately consider the available documentation. His attorneys argued that his removal was unlawful because he was a U.S. citizen and therefore was not subject to deportation under federal immigration law.
Evidence submitted during the litigation eventually changed the government’s position on his citizenship. His attorneys provided additional hospital records, witness affidavits and a certified birth record from Colorado. The documentation supported his account that he was born in Denver and established a stronger evidentiary basis for his citizenship claim.
Differences between his American and Mexican identification documents also became relevant to the dispute. The Texas Tribune previously reported that his Mexican identification contained a different spelling of his first name, using Bryan instead of Brian, as well as a different date of birth. His mother attributed the discrepancies to errors made by a clerk in Mexico who had not carefully checked his American documentation.
In late August, the federal government reached an agreement with Morales García’s attorneys that allowed him to return to the United States while the lawsuit continued. He returned on August 30 after spending approximately four months in Mexico. His attorney, Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch, traveled to Laredo to meet him following the agreement.
The return allowed Morales García to resume his life in Texas, but it did not end the legal dispute. In September, he told The Texas Tribune that he remained concerned about the possibility of another encounter with law enforcement. He questioned whether a future traffic stop could lead to the same treatment, even after his citizenship had been established through official documents.
The November 20 filing introduces a new dimension to the case. Federal attorneys are now explicitly acknowledging Morales García’s dual citizenship while asking the court to dismiss the claims against the federal government. Their argument centers on immunity in immigration enforcement, rather than a continued assertion that Morales García lacks American citizenship.

The distinction is important because acknowledging citizenship does not automatically establish legal liability for the officials involved. The court must still consider the claims raised in the lawsuit, the applicable legal protections for federal officials and the circumstances surrounding the original detention and removal. Judge Pitman had not issued a ruling on the government’s request as of November 20.
The Department of Homeland Security and Texas DPS did not immediately respond to questions from The Texas Tribune seeking comment on the latest filing. The federal government’s position on the dismissal request therefore remains the principal new development publicly documented in the case, alongside its explicit acknowledgment of Morales García’s citizenship.
The dispute also comes against a broader background of concerns about immigration enforcement involving American citizens. A July 2021 report by the U.S. Government Accountability Office found that available Immigration and Customs Enforcement data showed 674 arrests, 121 detentions and 70 removals involving potential U.S. citizens between fiscal year 2015 and the second quarter of fiscal year 2020.
The GAO also identified weaknesses in the way immigration authorities documented and reviewed citizenship claims. Its investigation found inconsistencies between ICE policy and training materials concerning supervisory review of individuals who claimed American citizenship. The agency recommended improving training and systematically collecting electronic records of encounters involving potential U.S. citizens. The Department of Homeland Security agreed with the recommendations.
More recently, an October 2025 investigation by ProPublica identified more than 170 incidents in which U.S. citizens were held against their will by immigration agents during the first nine months of President Donald Trump’s second administration. The newsroom compiled its own count from court records, lawsuits, media reports and other publicly available information because the federal government does not maintain a comprehensive accounting of such encounters. More than 50 of the documented cases involved citizens whose nationality was questioned by immigration agents. The investigation did not establish a comprehensive number of citizens who had been deported.
Morales García’s experience has also drawn attention to the role of state and local law enforcement in federal immigration operations. The initial encounter involved a state traffic stop, county sheriff’s deputies and federal immigration personnel. The subsequent lawsuit places the actions of those agencies under judicial scrutiny, although the responsibilities and potential liability of each defendant must be assessed separately.
For now, the federal government’s acknowledgment that Morales García is a dual U.S.-Mexican citizen marks a significant change in the official record, but the legal dispute remains unresolved. The judge’s decision on the immunity argument will determine whether the lawsuit can proceed against the federal government. The claims involving the other defendants also remain part of the broader litigation, leaving questions about the April detention and deportation before the court.




Leave a Reply