Immigration and Customs Enforcement arrests are continuing at Massachusetts courthouses and near other sensitive public locations, prompting renewed criticism from immigrant rights advocates following the implementation of the state’s PROTECT Act. A CBS Boston report published November 16 detailed a Boston family’s account of a father’s detention near a school, alongside advocacy group claims that ICE recorded 22 arrests at Massachusetts courthouses during the first 10 days of the law’s courthouse protections.

The incidents have intensified questions about the relationship between Massachusetts’ new restrictions on civil immigration enforcement and the federal government’s authority to conduct immigration operations. While state officials have expressed concern about reported enforcement activity, ICE maintains that federal law governs its operations.

One of the cases highlighted by CBS Boston involved a Boston mother whose husband was detained by ICE in early November while preparing to take their two youngest children to Gardner Pilot School in Allston. The woman, speaking through a translator and requesting anonymity, told the television station that the detention occurred in front of the couple’s 5-year-old and 4-year-old children.

According to her account, her mother-in-law called to report that the father had been detained and that the children were crying inside the vehicle. The woman said the arrest happened a short distance from the school, but not on school property. The detained man, a native of Honduras and father of three, remains in ICE custody at Plymouth County Correctional Facility, according to the report.

The mother said her husband had no criminal history and had lived in the United States since 2013. She also said he had a pending asylum claim. Those details were presented as the family’s account and were not independently established in the report. She described the detention as deeply disruptive to the family and expressed concern about the circumstances surrounding her husband’s arrest.

The location distinction is important under Massachusetts law. The PROTECT Act restricts civil immigration arrests on protected school grounds without a judicial warrant or judicial order. However, the reported arrest near Gardner Pilot School occurred outside school property. The incident therefore does not, by itself, establish that ICE violated the school’s location-specific protections, even as advocates argue that enforcement activity near educational facilities creates fear among immigrant families.

Governor Maura Healey signed the PROTECT Act, formally titled An Act Promoting Rule of Law, Oversight, Trust and Equal Constitutional Treatment, on August 5, 2026. The legislation establishes restrictions on civil immigration enforcement at several categories of sensitive locations, including public schools, charter schools, qualifying childcare facilities, covered healthcare facilities and state-controlled property.

The law’s provisions differ according to the type of location. At covered schools and childcare facilities, civil arrests are generally prohibited on protected premises without a judicial warrant or order, subject to specified legal exceptions. At covered healthcare facilities, the restrictions apply to designated nonpublic areas rather than automatically covering public lobbies and waiting rooms. The law also establishes protections concerning certain nonpublic areas of state property.

The courthouse provisions became effective on November 3, adding a separate layer of protection. Under Chapter 221D of Massachusetts law, a courthouse includes the interior of a facility where a state court conducts business and surrounding areas such as courtyards, plazas, steps, sidewalks, walkways and certain court-controlled parking facilities.

A Massachusetts courthouse and surrounding public area illustrate ongoing concerns over ICE arrests and the enforcement of the state's PROTECT Act.

The courthouse provisions establish specific requirements for civil arrests. Federal officers seeking to make a qualifying civil arrest at a courthouse must act in their official capacity and present documentation to a designated judge, justice or judicial magistrate demonstrating that the individual is covered by a judicial warrant or judicial order authorizing the arrest. The designated judicial officer must promptly review the documentation. The law separately prohibits civil arrests inside courtrooms.

The courthouse restrictions also distinguish civil immigration enforcement from arrests connected to criminal proceedings. Criminal arrests, contempt proceedings and certain judicial, probation and parole warrants fall outside the statute’s definition of civil arrest. Consequently, the reported number of ICE arrests cannot automatically be treated as the number of violations of the PROTECT Act.

Concerns about enforcement at Massachusetts courthouses predate the latest CBS Boston report. On November 4, GBH News reported that immigrant rights advocates alleged a violation on the first day the courthouse provisions took effect. Gladys Vega, president of the Chelsea-based nonprofit La Colaborativa, described witnessing federal agents detain a man after a court hearing. She said the agents had not shown a warrant during the incident.

The Massachusetts Trial Court system confirmed that a detention had taken place, according to GBH. However, court officials explained that they could not establish whether a judicial warrant existed because the detained individual’s identity was unknown. The Trial Court also reiterated that its employees were not permitted to interfere with or assist federal immigration authorities conducting arrests. A spokesperson for Attorney General Andrea Campbell’s office said the office was aware of the incident and was in contact with the Trial Court and La Colaborativa.

The latest figures have added to those concerns. According to the LUCE Immigrant Justice Network of Massachusetts, security systems at Massachusetts courts recorded 22 ICE arrests between November 3 and November 12. The figure was reported by CBS Boston, which attributed the information to the advocacy network. The report did not provide a case-by-case breakdown of the arrests, including whether judicial warrants were presented or how each incident was classified under the statute.

LUCE representatives argue that the continued enforcement activity undermines the legislation’s purpose. Pietra Adami, workers’ rights coordinator for the Brazilian Women’s Group and LUCE, said state leaders needed to take a more active role in implementing the law. Her criticism centers on the difference between establishing legal protections and ensuring that those protections operate effectively in practice.

The Healey administration acknowledged the reports. A spokesperson for the governor’s office told CBS Boston that the administration was closely monitoring ICE activity in Massachusetts communities, including at courthouses. The statement said the governor’s office was communicating with the Attorney General’s Office and evaluating possible responses. The Attorney General’s Office did not return CBS Boston’s request for comment before publication.

ICE, meanwhile, defended its enforcement practices and challenged the premise that Massachusetts’ restrictions control federal immigration operations. In a statement to CBS Boston, an agency spokesperson cited the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution, arguing that federal law takes precedence over conflicting state restrictions.

A Massachusetts courthouse and surrounding public area illustrate ongoing concerns over ICE arrests and the enforcement of the state's PROTECT Act.

The agency also rejected the characterization that it routinely plans operations targeting schools, hospitals, churches or polling locations. ICE described its approach as intelligence-driven targeted enforcement and said arrests could occur near sensitive locations when an active public safety threat was involved. The agency further defended courthouse arrests on operational and officer-safety grounds, arguing that individuals appearing at court are already subject to security screening.

The disagreement reflects a broader legal and institutional challenge. Massachusetts has established state-level restrictions and enforcement mechanisms, but federal immigration authorities maintain that their operations are governed by federal law. Whether particular enforcement actions violate the state statute, and how any resulting disputes will be resolved, depends on the specific circumstances and applicable legal proceedings.

The PROTECT Act assigns important enforcement responsibilities to the Massachusetts Attorney General’s Office. State law enforcement training materials explain that local and state police are not given authority to enforce, interpret or independently supervise compliance with the statute. They are also not required to interfere with or assist federal officers conducting civil immigration enforcement. The Attorney General’s Office and the courts therefore have central roles in addressing alleged violations.

The legislation also establishes legal remedies for individuals affected by certain prohibited arrests, including the ability to seek habeas corpus relief under the applicable provisions. The Attorney General may pursue civil actions concerning violations of the protected-location requirements. Separately, the act creates a state-law civil rights claim concerning constitutional violations committed under color of law, subject to the applicable legal standards and defenses.

For Massachusetts immigrant communities, the consequences extend beyond the immediate legal dispute. Advocates argue that visible immigration enforcement near schools and courthouses can discourage families from using educational, medical and judicial services. The concern is particularly significant for children who may witness a parent’s detention or experience uncertainty about a family’s ability to remain together.

The latest reports do not establish that every arrest identified by advocates violated the PROTECT Act, nor do they resolve the constitutional disagreement between state and federal authorities. They do, however, demonstrate that the law’s implementation is facing scrutiny shortly after its courthouse provisions took effect.

As of November 16, Healey’s administration had confirmed that it was monitoring the situation and evaluating its options with the Attorney General’s Office. ICE had maintained its position on federal enforcement authority, while immigrant rights organizations continued to call for stronger implementation of the state protections. The reported courthouse arrests and the Boston family’s account have placed the practical enforcement of the PROTECT Act at the center of Massachusetts’ ongoing immigration policy debate.

Leave a Reply

Trending